Thursday, February 12, 2015

Cody Tarlow's Blog Post #3: Rags, Critics, and Integration

In the 1930’s “Swing Era,” race become explicitly written and talked about after integration between blacks and whites in jazz bands forced the issue into the limelight. This discussion was fueled by the opinion pieces of jazz critics and the press.
Starting in the 1930’s many jazz bands became integrated. According to Stowe (1996), “by 1941 the barriers that had previously stood against integrated bands had fallen, with Goodman’s hiring of Christian and Henderson and Krupa’s hiring of Eldridge” (p. 129). This integration removed the comfortable divisions that had existed between the all-white and all-black bands in earlier decades, forcing the populace to open a discussion of the role of race in jazz. An example of one form this took was a Pittsburgh Courier columnist of the era who “urged musicians to shun the newly integrated white bands, promoters, and unions as the ‘enemy’” (Stowe, 1996, p. 61). Other sources in the media took radically different approaches to the issue. Down Beat, founded in 1934, was the first American magazine that featured African-American music and jazz regularly. As Stowe (2011) puts it, “Down Beat proudly noted its editorial policy of judging musicians ‘strictly on their ability and not on any basis of the complexion of their skin,’ and ventured that ‘most white musicians do not recognize color lines in music’” (p. 75). Downbeat blazed the path as a liberal Afro-positive publication in an age of increasing hysteria of jazz band integration.
Even more vocal than the journalists were the jazz critics of the era, the most legendary of which was the outspoken critic John Hammond. Hammond deliberately rejected “what he described as ‘the highly publicized Negro jazz bands, some of whom have made serious concessions to white taste by adding spurious showmanship to their wares…’ [to recruit] what he regarded as the genuine authentic performers of African-American music” (Stowe, 1996, p.  61). Hammond’s is a viewpoint that mixes many different interplays of race and music. Unlike the Pittsburgh columnist, Hammond actually believes that white imitations of jazz are diluting and corrupting the purer African-American forms of jazz. This goes to show that the debate about race and jazz was not always about civil rights; often it took the form of “which race played better jazz.” Hammond did not ignore the civil rights aspect of jazz music however. He often put the impetus on the musicians to sustain their racial burden on behalf of “their people.” He even went as far as criticizing black musicians that he felt did not carry this racial burden well enough. Stowe (1996) notes “Ellington’s tact and suave manner disguised a willingness to tolerate racial indignities for the sake of commercial success, according to Hammond, and stripped both the bandleader and his music of the moral authority he thought they should possess” (p. 51). To properly contextualize this quote it should be pointed out that Hammond was a white critic. This brings up the issue of a non-African American telling an African American what he should or should not do as a member of a separate ethnic group. Of course Hammond also walked the walk as a member in many societies dedicated to civil rights for African Americans and a vocal advocate for ending segregation. On the other hand, he (Hammond actually inherited a large amount of money and did not have to work a single day in his life) and the other white jazz critics led lives completely separated from the daily struggle that jazz musicians went through just to survive and the compromises they often had to make to appease white audiences.

References

Gioia, T. (2011). The History of Jazz (2.nd ed.). New York: Oxford Univ. Press.

Stowe, D. (1994). Swing changes: Big-band jazz in New Deal America. Cambridge, Mass.: Harvard University Press.

I commented on Rebekah Ent's blog post.


Thursday, February 5, 2015

Cody Tarlow Blog #2: Fats Waller and the Racial and Socio-economic Aspects of Stride Piano

           Unlike the largely stagnant importation of talent from New Orleans that Chicago featured, New York birthed its own forms of Jazz, furthering the art. One of these was the style of stride piano. This style did not arise in a vacuum, but out of a specific set of economic, social, and racial conditions.
Racially, Harlem experienced a huge shift in demographics in the years following the start of World War I. In Harlem “the African American population boomed, with southern migrants joining refugees from the overcrowded midtown tenements of Manhattan” (Gioia, 2011, p. 90). This shift set the tableau for stride to come into existence as it was a highly racialized form, especially at its conception. Much of Harlem was a slum, but just saying it was a slum would not be giving it enough credit as the powerful cultural force that it was. After the Harlem Renaissance, an invigorated artistic undercurrent ran through the city, not just affecting literature and the visual arts, but music as well. Of course no new style can emerge without the means to produce it, and the means of the stride style is the piano. In the years before World War I “there was a piano in almost every home. The piano makers had a slogan: “What Is Home Without A Piano?” (Lyttelton, 1999, p. 24). The possession of a piano was not enough however. There needed to be social and economic reasons driving the listeners and players of the style. As Lyttelton (1999) notes “Most people who had pianos couldn’t play them, so a piano-player was important socially. There were so many of them visiting and socializing that some people would have their pianos going day and night all week long” (p. 24). The stride piano player existed squarely in social space. He brought people together and created an environment for social bonding. That is not to say, however, that there were not self-interested economic motivations in play as well. According to Gioai (2011), “the Harlem of rent parties and underground economies created music. Even before the onset of the Great Depression, the rent party had become established as an accepted way of paying for the high cost of lodging” (p. 90). Ironically poverty and desperation, after engaging with the social and cultural aspects of the new Harlem, also acted as a mechanism for driving the elements that created the new musical form.
            Thomas “Fats” Waller may not had the gravitas of Louis Armstrong or the stunning innovation of Art Tatum, but he was New York Jazz. Fats Waller “displayed a knack for captivating audiences unsurpassed by any jazz musician, past or present” (Gioia, 2011, p. 92). Fats Waller, in the classical New York sense, was a true showman and entertainer. A larger than life personality and jokester, he truly encapsulated the strange dichotomy that was prohibition New York. This being said, New York jazz was not all swagger. Fats Waller was also classically trained at Julliard, a reflection the cosmopolitan influences New York had on jazz as a place of great classical concerts and operas. Additionally, as Gioia (2011) puts it, “His activities took him anywhere and everywhere the entertainment industry flourished, from the theaters of Broadway to the motion picture studios of Hollywood” (p. 96). New York jazz is uniquely influenced by Broadway and the silver screen. Fats Waller could not have embodied New York jazz without having participated in these institutions. A classically trained Harlem-born stride piano player, who was a first rate showman, involved with Broadway and appearing in motion pictures? If anything is New York jazz that is it.

References

Gioia, T. (2011). The history of jazz (2nd ed.). New York: Oxford Univ. Press.

Lyttelton, H. (1999). The best of jazz. London: Robson.



I commented on Jenny Eberle’s blog.