Unlike the largely
stagnant importation of talent from New Orleans that Chicago featured, New York
birthed its own forms of Jazz, furthering the art. One of these was the style
of stride piano. This style did not arise in a vacuum, but out of a specific set
of economic, social, and racial conditions.
Racially,
Harlem experienced a huge shift in demographics in the years following the
start of World War I. In Harlem “the African American population boomed, with
southern migrants joining refugees from the overcrowded midtown tenements of Manhattan”
(Gioia, 2011, p. 90). This shift set the tableau for stride to come into
existence as it was a highly racialized form, especially at its conception.
Much of Harlem was a slum, but just saying it was a slum would not be giving it
enough credit as the powerful cultural force that it was. After the Harlem
Renaissance, an invigorated artistic undercurrent ran through the city, not
just affecting literature and the visual arts, but music as well. Of course no
new style can emerge without the means to produce it, and the means of the
stride style is the piano. In the years before World War I “there was a piano
in almost every home. The piano makers had a slogan: “What Is Home Without A
Piano?” (Lyttelton, 1999, p. 24). The possession of a piano was not enough however.
There needed to be social and economic reasons driving the listeners and
players of the style. As Lyttelton (1999) notes “Most people who had pianos couldn’t
play them, so a piano-player was important socially. There were so many of them
visiting and socializing that some people would have their pianos going day and
night all week long” (p. 24). The stride piano player existed squarely in
social space. He brought people together and created an environment for social
bonding. That is not to say, however, that there were not self-interested
economic motivations in play as well. According to Gioai (2011), “the Harlem of rent
parties and underground economies created music. Even before the onset of the
Great Depression, the rent party had become established as an accepted way of
paying for the high cost of lodging” (p. 90). Ironically poverty and
desperation, after engaging with the social and cultural aspects of the new
Harlem, also acted as a mechanism for driving the elements that created the new
musical form.
Thomas “Fats” Waller may not had the gravitas of Louis
Armstrong or the stunning innovation of Art Tatum, but he was New York Jazz. Fats
Waller “displayed a knack for captivating audiences unsurpassed by any jazz
musician, past or present” (Gioia, 2011, p. 92). Fats Waller, in the classical
New York sense, was a true showman and entertainer. A larger than life
personality and jokester, he truly encapsulated the strange dichotomy that was
prohibition New York. This being said, New York jazz was not all swagger. Fats
Waller was also classically trained at Julliard, a reflection the cosmopolitan
influences New York had on jazz as a place of great classical concerts and
operas. Additionally, as Gioia (2011) puts it, “His activities took him
anywhere and everywhere the entertainment industry flourished, from the theaters
of Broadway to the motion picture studios of Hollywood” (p. 96). New York jazz
is uniquely influenced by Broadway and the silver screen. Fats Waller could not
have embodied New York jazz without having participated in these institutions.
A classically trained Harlem-born stride piano player, who was a first rate
showman, involved with Broadway and appearing in motion pictures? If anything
is New York jazz that is it.
References
Gioia, T. (2011). The history of jazz (2nd ed.). New York: Oxford Univ. Press.
Lyttelton, H.
(1999). The best of jazz. London: Robson.
I commented on Jenny Eberle’s blog.
You make an interesting point here in claiming that the poverty and desperation of the Southern immigrants and tenement owners of Harlem's slums was the driving force of New York's unique Jazz style. I think it is very true that a lot of talent and musicality stemmed from the rent parties and musically centered social gathering in these tight quarters. However, I believe New York's style was distinct from that of Chicago's per the existence of a huge market in the upper and middle class white demographic that existed and was open to Jazz there. The bridging of Jazz from its blues and country roots to an art meant for the stages of Broadway created the form of Jazz that went on to take over the national music stage, though it would remain a Black art at heart.
ReplyDeleteI really like your take on the evolution of jazz in New York, because I took it more in the sense that it evolved differently from Chicago because there was more of an middle-to-upper class influence on the artists, with the addition of the piano and such. Though its different from my perspective, I agree with how the music evolved in the rent parties and other gatherings. It seems that the interaction between the upper and lower class together is what evolved the music into the New York Jazz form.
ReplyDeleteI love that you focused on one instrument in your discussion of New York jazz. It goes without saying that the piano is instrumental in the creation of the Harlem stride style. I am glad that you placed all of that information within the context of how Harlem stride was racially developed. I used the half of the same 'rent parties' quote from Gioia in my own blog. I definitely agree that it's important to emphasize that Harlem stride wasn't a direct result of the Harlem renaissance, but a result of its collision with new southern residents and their 'raucous' antics.
ReplyDelete