Monday, March 9, 2015

Blog #5: Lessons Learned

            “If you have talented, quality musicians who are willing to work hard, play hard, and do it together, then you can make a great band” (Davis, 1989, p. 273). Miles always stresses how important collaboration and synergy are to jazz bands. Before taking this class I had a very different view of jazz bands. I always thought of the soloist in front as the real “band” and the other players as support. Of course this is a viewpoint that most musicians abhor. I have learned that the other players are not replaceable cogs. In fact as Dizzy Gillespie and many others have said, a lot of times creating the right combination of musicians is more important than getting the absolute “best” musicians. If this principle is ignored it can end up akin to an NBA all-star team which is full of the best players in the country but cannot work properly together as a unit. In fact I have learned that sometimes a selfish soloist can have a detrimental effect on a previously cohesive jazz band. Miles relates an experience illustrating this phenomenon. “In the last years of that Trane was with my group, he started playing for himself, especially during the last year. When that happens the magic is gone out of a band and people who used to love to play together start not caring anymore. And that’s when a band falls apart, and all the music gets stale” (Davis, 1989, p. 273). Miles talks about Trane playing for himself. There is a certain amount of hubris that comes to many great soloists after achieving renown. This hubris leads them to stop communicating with their fellow band members. I have learned that within jazz pieces there are subtle communications between musicians. The best pieces happen when musicians are riffing off one another and talking through their instruments. Trane violated this principle and the band paid the price. Part of this is being open to the innovations and ideas of your band members. As Davis (1989) puts it, “those were all young guys and although they were learning from me, I was learning from them, too, about the new thing, the free thing. Because to be and stay a great musician you’ve got to always be open to what’s new” (p. 273). Miles stayed relevant by listening to and incorporating the ideas of his band members even if they were younger, less famous, and less experienced than him. This is another form of communication important to jazz bands that I had never really considered before, the improvisation of ideas. Miles, unlike Monk who largely operated within his own artistic sphere and later fell out of popularity, retained his international renown by always changing it up and being open to new ideas and new forms of expression no matter the source. This can be heard directly in his albums which explore many different sounds and moods within jazz and are very different from one another artistically.

References

Davis, M., & Troupe, Q. (1989). Miles, the autobiography. New York: Simon and Schuster.


I commented on Emily Wettleson's blog.

2 comments:

  1. I really enjoyed your blog. I loved the way you emphasized Davis's importance of synergy. He really was amazing in that regard. A team's chemistry is what makes them strong, nobody knew this better than Davis. Great job.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This is an interesting perspective on jazz, that while it is an improvisational art that places an importance on solos, band cohesion is critical to the generation of quality music and even benefits the solos within a band. I had the opposite conception of jazz before this course and thought that it was an orchestrated and concerted art form more than improvisational, the true form of jazz seems to be in between.

    ReplyDelete