Jazz can be both an expression of hardships and shared tragedy and an
outlet for community and creativity. That is why “Jazz is New York, man,” not
because it can only exist in New York but because New York, specifically San
Juan Hill, is so jazz-like. Leimert Park, which shares so many of the
characteristics of this metaphor, is also jazz (as the residents can attest to).
Both Leimert Park and San Juan Hill in the 1920’s are communities steeped
in systematic and racialized violence that deeply affect the residents within.
“The daily violence young people endured in San Juan Hill haunted Thelonius for
many years to come” (Kelley, 2009, p. 18). Much of the violence grew out of the
racial tensions in a highly diverse neighborhood. This created in Monk an
aversion to violence that later caused him to shy away from the more militant
forms of black enfranchisement during civil rights movement. As Monk puts it, “I
did all that fighting with ofays (whites) when I was a kid. We had to fight to
make it so we could walk the streets. There’s no reason why I should go through
that Black Power shit now” (Kelley, 2009, p. 19). Just like the residents of
Leimert Park’s descriptions of being harassed by the police, Monk often had
negative encounters with law enforcement. “The police didn’t help matters, as
far as Monk was concerned. They epitomized racism in the city” (Kelley, 2009,
p. 19).
Of course, just like Leimert Park, juxtaposing the poverty and violence
of San Juan Hill was a vibrant music scene that was often ignored. “Stories of
crime and violence dominated newspapers accounts of San Juan Hill... what
newspapers rarely covered was San Juan Hill's rich musical culture” (Kelley,
2009, p. 19). Leimert Park and San Juan Hill both boast a large number of black
musicians. These black musicians tutored and encouraged the young Monk. “Before
the Harlem Renaissance pushed the black musical center of gravity up above
125th street, the West Side, from the Tenderloin - also known as "Black
Bohemia" - to San Juan Hill boasted the largest concentration of black
musicians in the city” (Kelley, 2009, p. 19). Inner city “renaissances” are
often spoken of as if they just sprung from a set of atmospheric conditions,
but it is the residents and artists themselves who create and foster the
movement.
Despite San Juan’s diversity as a tendency to be a catalyst for violence,
Monk also benefited from the differing cultural influences of the varied
population. Especially influential to Monk because of their proximity and number
in San Juan Hill were the Caribbean residents, many of which formed Monk’s
friends and neighbors. This was an influence later clearly expressed in many of
his compositional pieces. “Thelonius absorbed Caribbean music... one can
certainly hear explicit Caribbean rhythms in some of Monk's original
compositions” (Kelley, 2009, p. 23).
Finally Thelonius was influenced by public, open-air concerts which took
place in a park much like the one seen in the documentary about Leimert Park. “Barbara
did what she could to introduce her children to the city's rich cultural life.
She frequently took them to Central Park in the summer to hear Edwin Franko
Goldman's sixty piece orchestra perform classical works by European and
American composers” (Kelley, 2009, p. 22). Open air concerts created an
atmosphere of musical celebration and community that was an important refuge
from the poverty, violence, and discrimination in both Leimert Park and San
Juan Hill.
References
Kelley,
R. (2009). Thelonious Monk: The life and
times of an American original. New
York: Free Press.
I commented on Rebekah Ent's blog post.
Cody,
ReplyDeleteI agree it seems jazz was a form of expression as a reaction to the hardships Black communities faced. However, I'm wondering if you think jazz was more of a passive outlet for musicians, or if it was a way to actively unite the community in the face of discrimination?